Sunday, November 16, 2014

Error in MIDI bass part

Lloyd Mendes of the bass section writes:

I believe there's an error in the practice MIDI file downloaded from your website, the bass part for Bach's cantata, 3_sicut, minute 1:55.  The sheet music shows in measure 58 ("et nunc et") A D A, but the MIDI file plays A D B.  I once saw Batman and Robin deduce that the Joker had kidnapped the Symphony's Maestro using just this kind of analysis, and while I don't want to spread unfounded terror in Gotham City, well, I'm just sayin'


Well, Lloyd, I haven't done the listening to confirm the error, but I have no reason to doubt you. As for the Dynamic Duo, I really can't help you there. Basses: listen up for this error!




No comments:

Post a Comment